Calculators
Investment SimulatorWhat would $X in an ETF, stock or crypto be worth today?DCA CalculatorInvest a fixed amount every month and see the result.Compound InterestProject your savings, TFSA or RRSP over the years.Budget PlannerFind how much you can invest each month.
Learn
GuidesETF & stock returnsCompare ETFsMethodologyFAQ
Premium
Pricing
International and stylesUpdated Nov 13, 2026

VNQ vs SPY: which did better?

Vanguard Real Estate ETF compared with SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust over the 22.2 years they both traded, from September 2004 to Nov 13, 2026.

VNQ

U.S. ETFs · USD
+3.0%/yr
$10,000 → $19,198 · worst drop -71%
vs

SPY

U.S. ETFs · USD
+9.0%/yr
$10,000 → $67,499 · worst drop -52%

The short answer

SPY did better, by about 6.0 percentage points a year (+3.0% vs +9.0%). SPY held up better in its worst drop (-52% vs -71%). VNQ beat SPY in 6 of 21 full calendar years, and over 36% of all rolling 12-month periods. Their monthly returns were only moderately related (correlation 0.74): they behave differently and can play different roles in a portfolio.

Growth of $10,000

Invested in September 2004 in each, price only, each in its own currency.

Side by side

Common period September 2004 – Nov 13, 2026, except trailing returns (each fund's own history).

VNQSPY
Annual return+3.0%+9.0%
Total return+92%+575%
$10,000 became$19,198$67,499
Worst drop-71%-52%
Volatility (yearly)21.3%14.8%
1-year return+7.9%+12.3%
3-year return (per year)+8.8%+19.7%
5-year return (per year)-2.5%+10.1%
10-year return (per year)+2.1%+13.3%
Typical yield (not included above)~3.9%~1.9%
CurrencyUSDUSD

Year by year

VNQ beat SPY in 6 of 21 full calendar years, and over 36% of all rolling 12-month periods.

YearVNQSPYDifference
2025-0.7%+16.4%SPY +17.0%
2024+0.8%+23.3%SPY +22.5%
2023+7.1%+24.3%SPY +17.2%
2022-28.9%-19.5%SPY +9.4%
2021+36.6%+27.0%VNQ +9.6%
2020-8.5%+16.2%SPY +24.6%
2019+24.4%+28.8%SPY +4.4%
2018-10.1%-6.3%SPY +3.8%
2017+0.5%+19.4%SPY +18.8%
2016+3.5%+9.6%SPY +6.1%
2015-1.6%-0.8%SPY +0.8%
2014+25.5%+11.3%VNQ +14.2%
2013-1.9%+29.7%SPY +31.6%
2012+13.4%+13.5%SPY +0.0%
2011+4.7%-0.2%VNQ +4.9%
2010+23.8%+12.8%VNQ +10.9%
2009+22.7%+23.5%SPY +0.7%
2008-40.7%-38.3%SPY +2.4%
2007-20.2%+3.2%SPY +23.4%
2006+29.3%+13.7%VNQ +15.5%
2005+5.3%+3.0%VNQ +2.3%

Worst drops

VNQ fell -71.5% from January 2007 to February 2009; SPY fell -52.2% from October 2007 to February 2009 (month-end prices).

đź”’
How would a mix of VNQ and SPY have handled 2008, 2020 and 2022?
Premium compares up to 4 funds after fees and in Canadian dollars, replays every major crash and shows recovery times. Try it free for 7 days

VNQ vs SPY questions

Which performed better, VNQ or SPY?
From September 2004 to Nov 13, 2026 (22.2 years), VNQ returned 3.0% a year and SPY 9.0% a year, based on split-adjusted closing prices. $10,000 grew to $19,198 in VNQ and $67,499 in SPY.
Which one fell more in downturns?
Over the same period, VNQ's worst drop was -71.5% (January 2007 to February 2009) and SPY's was -52.2% (October 2007 to February 2009).
Are VNQ and SPY basically the same?
Their monthly returns were only moderately related (correlation 0.74): they behave differently and can play different roles in a portfolio.
Do these returns include dividends and fees?
They are price returns: each fund's management fees are already taken out of its price, but distributions are not added back. Typical yields are about 3.9% for VNQ and 1.9% for SPY, which would add to the totals if reinvested.

Historical closing prices adjusted for stock splits, from Google Finance, cleaned and updated daily by WhatIfInvested. Month-end prices are used for the common-period figures. Distributions are not included. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This page is for education only and is not investment advice.

Free monthly email

One “What if” a month

A real backtest in plain English, the month’s biggest market moves for Canadian investors, and new tools. No spam — unsubscribe in one click.

Scroll to Top