Calculators
Investment SimulatorWhat would $X in an ETF, stock or crypto be worth today?DCA CalculatorInvest a fixed amount every month and see the result.Compound InterestProject your savings, TFSA or RRSP over the years.Budget PlannerFind how much you can invest each month.
Learn
GuidesETF & stock returnsCompare ETFsMethodologyFAQ
Premium
Pricing
Dividend ETFsUpdated Nov 13, 2026

VYM vs VIG: which did better?

Vanguard High Dividend Yield Index Fund ETF compared with Vanguard Dividend Appreciation over the 20.0 years they both traded, from November 2006 to Nov 13, 2026.

VYM

U.S. ETFs · USD
+6.1%/yr
$10,000 → $32,541 · worst drop -54%
vs

VIG

U.S. ETFs · USD
+8.1%/yr
$10,000 → $47,335 · worst drop -43%

The short answer

VIG did better, by about 2.0 percentage points a year (+6.1% vs +8.1%). VIG held up better in its worst drop (-43% vs -54%). VYM beat VIG in 8 of 19 full calendar years, and over 47% of all rolling 12-month periods. Their monthly returns were closely related (correlation 0.95) but not interchangeable: they hold different mixes, which explains most of the gap.

Growth of $10,000

Invested in November 2006 in each, price only, each in its own currency.

Side by side

Common period November 2006 – Nov 13, 2026, except trailing returns (each fund's own history).

VYMVIG
Annual return+6.1%+8.1%
Total return+225%+373%
$10,000 became$32,541$47,335
Worst drop-54%-43%
Volatility (yearly)14.7%13.5%
1-year return+16.8%+15.7%
3-year return (per year)+17.2%+16.6%
5-year return (per year)+8.3%+8.5%
10-year return (per year)+8.5%+11.7%
Typical yield (not included above)~3.0%~1.9%
CurrencyUSDUSD

Year by year

VYM beat VIG in 8 of 19 full calendar years, and over 47% of all rolling 12-month periods.

YearVYMVIGDifference
2025+12.5%+12.2%VYM +0.3%
2024+14.3%+14.9%VIG +0.6%
2023+3.2%+12.2%VIG +9.1%
2022-3.5%-11.6%VYM +8.1%
2021+22.5%+21.7%VYM +0.8%
2020-2.3%+13.2%VIG +15.6%
2019+20.2%+27.3%VIG +7.1%
2018-8.9%-4.0%VIG +4.9%
2017+13.0%+19.8%VIG +6.8%
2016+13.5%+9.5%VYM +4.0%
2015-2.9%-4.2%VYM +1.3%
2014+10.3%+7.9%VYM +2.4%
2013+26.2%+26.3%VIG +0.1%
2012+9.1%+9.0%VYM +0.1%
2011+7.2%+3.8%VYM +3.4%
2010+11.1%+12.3%VIG +1.2%
2009+13.1%+16.7%VIG +3.6%
2008-34.2%-28.3%VIG +6.0%
2007-1.2%+4.0%VIG +5.2%

Worst drops

VYM fell -54.4% from May 2007 to February 2009; VIG fell -42.7% from September 2007 to February 2009 (month-end prices).

đź”’
How would a mix of VYM and VIG have handled 2008, 2020 and 2022?
Premium compares up to 4 funds after fees and in Canadian dollars, replays every major crash and shows recovery times. Try it free for 7 days

VYM vs VIG questions

Which performed better, VYM or VIG?
From November 2006 to Nov 13, 2026 (20.0 years), VYM returned 6.1% a year and VIG 8.1% a year, based on split-adjusted closing prices. $10,000 grew to $32,541 in VYM and $47,335 in VIG.
Which one fell more in downturns?
Over the same period, VYM's worst drop was -54.4% (May 2007 to February 2009) and VIG's was -42.7% (September 2007 to February 2009).
Are VYM and VIG basically the same?
Their monthly returns were closely related (correlation 0.95) but not interchangeable: they hold different mixes, which explains most of the gap.
Do these returns include dividends and fees?
They are price returns: each fund's management fees are already taken out of its price, but distributions are not added back. Typical yields are about 3.0% for VYM and 1.9% for VIG, which would add to the totals if reinvested.

Historical closing prices adjusted for stock splits, from Google Finance, cleaned and updated daily by WhatIfInvested. Month-end prices are used for the common-period figures. Distributions are not included. Past performance does not guarantee future results. This page is for education only and is not investment advice.

Free monthly email

One “What if” a month

A real backtest in plain English, the month’s biggest market moves for Canadian investors, and new tools. No spam — unsubscribe in one click.

Scroll to Top